What are the Best Restaurants in Milford?

No matter if you’re looking for the perfect take-out around Sparta Twp or a spot near Hackettstown that delivers proper accommodations for a safe dining experience, we’re here to compile some of the best restaurants in Milford, PA. All options offer a range of take-out as well as distanced or outdoor seating to meet your needs. With a range of options to suit your budget and cravings, you’ll have no trouble finding a great place to eat around town. Check out some of our picks for the best Milford restaurants, and see how you can find your next Honda among our inventory at Sussex Honda!

Waterwheel Cafe

The Waterwheel Cafe, Bakery, and Bar has been a neighborhood favorite since 1989! Offering contemporary dishes with modern Vietnamese flair, they have a wide variety of flavorful lunch and dinner options to choose from. You’ll love the beautiful atmosphere plus the spacious patio seating for a relaxing and enjoyable meal on your next weekday or weekend outing.

Balch’s Seafood Restaurant

Don’t let the name fool you— Balch’s Seafood Restaurant offers not only quality seafood staples, but also has a seasonal Oktoberfest menu with classic German dishes like potato pancakes and Sauerbratan. With a spacious back deck and produce from their own garden, Balch’s is the perfect choice for your next night out.

Village Diner

You’ll be transported back to the 50’s when you visit Village Diner in Milford! Built in 1956, dining here is a classic Americana experience. Whether dining in or ordering carryout, you’ll be able to indulge in some classic, homemade food made from scratch, including burgers, wraps, and breakfast served all day.

John’s of Arthur Avenue

John’s of Arthur Avenue is your one-stop shop for the perfect pie as you’ll have plenty of great classics to choose from, including New York style, Naples style, Sicilian style, and Italian-American classic pizzas. For those looking for a hearty bite on the go, they offer tasty sandwiches, wings, pasta, and calzones that are sure to hit the spot.

Apple Valley Family Restaurant

When you visit Apple Valley Family Restaurant, not only will you enjoy a meal, but you can experience the ambiance of a village of small shops, walking paths, and even a duck pond! Enjoy their patio seating and a selection from their menu which offers classic American food including wraps, wings, salads, and burgers.

Find More of the Best Milford Restaurants at Sussex Honda

With some of the best Milford restaurants offering a range of options with all of the accommodations you need, it’s easy to find a great meal to feed yourself or the whole gang around Denville. Explore more local features at Sussex Honda including where you can find some of the best bakeries in the area for all of your home favorites and plenty of surprises. Plus, be sure to check out our inventory of new and used specials to keep you moving around town with ease. Contact us today for more information on some of the best restaurants in Milford and schedule a test drive at our Honda dealership for your next ride!